Popular Posts

Sunday, January 08, 2006

A Dangerous Question

Reporters Without Borders, an organization that wants to protect and encourage free speech around the world, asks a big question: "Do Internet companies need to be regulated to ensure they respect free expression?"
There's a surface appeal to this proposal. But it gives me the shivers. The idea is impractical, for one thing. And if we ask for regulation of speech -- even under the principle of protecting it -- we may be inviting the wrong kind of interference later on.
I have no brief for the companies that have all but forced such questions to the surface with their amoral behavior. The litany of officially sanctioned censorship grows longer every day -- and U.S. technology companies complicity in repressive governments' clampdowns on political speech is downright repulsive.
To its credit, Reporters Without Borders recognizes the matter's complexity, and doesn't make its suggestion lightly. Moreover, the organization has been trying to achieve its goals in other ways:
Reporters Without Borders has written to the chief executives of several corporations since 2002 proposing an exchange of ideas on this issue. None of our letters have been answered. We have also tried to alert the shareholders of these companies through investment funds. We presented a joint statement on 7 November in New York in which 25 investment firms managing some 21 billion dollars in assets undertook to monitor the activities of Internet companies operating in repressive countries.
Aside from Google, all the companies we approached refused to enter into a dialogue on this subject. We would therefore now like the American people’s elected representatives and the Department of State to formally take up this issue.
An actual law to address this should only become a "last resort," the organization says, and this should be a two-step process:
Initially, a group of congressmen should formally ask Internet corporations to reach an agreement among themselves on a code of conduct that includes the recommendations we make at the end of this document. The companies would be urged to use the help of organisations specialised in freedom of expression in drafting the document. The request would include a deadline for the companies to submit their draft code of conduct to the congressmen concerned.
In the event that no satisfactory code of conduct has been drawn up when the deadline expires, or the proposed code has not been accepted by a sufficient number of representative companies, the congressmen would set about drafting a law that would aim to ensure that US companies respect freedom of expression when they are operating in repressive countries and elsewhere.
Which members of Congress does Reporters Without Borders propose to approach? The ones who might cause the technology execs to listen -- in a Washington utterly dominated by people who favor business' desires over just about all else -- are the least likely to get involved. I doubt that Cisco's John Chambers, whose company is one of the primary enablers of censorship, would offer more than a tiny bit of lip service if, say, Zoe Lofgren (a Democrat who represents San Jose, Cisco's home town, in Congress) raised this issue.
Perhaps some Democrats, plus Republicans whose main motive would be to embarrass the Chinese regime, would come up with a "code of conduct" along these lines. The chances of its passage might be higher than we'd think, if it actually came to the floors of the House and Senate, because it would be difficult for incumbents to explain at election time why they favored censorship elsewhere but defended free speech (assuming they do) at home. But it would never get to the floor, for that reason.
Then there's the question of how or whether such a law would work. I can't begin to imagine how it would be enforced. How would we distinguish among the various cases that would be sure to arise, such as whether a site was taken down for political reasons or because it genuinely violated reasonable terms of service? Who wants that job, anyway? And what kind of penalties for noncompliance would we establish?
But the chief problem with this proposal is not whether it could pass or is practical. The very notion of governments telling companies how they must behave on matters of speech is worrisome in the first place.
Do we invite different kinds of interference down the road when we ask governments to be the arbiter of what speech is allowable and what isn't? I fear we do. The U.S. government is growing visibly hostile to the First Amendment even today, and America is heading in the wrong direction on free speech in a general way. Maybe we should tend to our own backyard before we tell our neighbor how to weed his garden.
Nonetheless, the answers aren't easy, as Rebecca MacKinnon says today, "but we need a lot more intelligent public debate on this."

12 comments:

knowitallman said...

Many motorists have acknowledged their radar detector in making them aware of their speed before they potentially lost control of their vehicle due to excessive speeds. Find out more about mountain radar detectors

speeders said...

If you find yourself in the market for a radar detector, you will probably be overwhelmed at the sheer volume of choices available. There are a variety of models and manufacturers for a radar detector for purchase, but how do you know which detector is a good investment? Begin by setting a budget, but beware: you get what you pay for! Strive to purchase the best radar detector for your money to ensure your investment will work well and last for a while to come. find out more at what states are radar detectors legal in

Rebek said...

All I can say is wow what a great job! The other half and I just got back from our friends house (well actually her friends house) and I needed a big break. I am working on a business project right now that is based on e commerce web hosting. I have literally been on-line for 4-5 hours doing research. Even though your blog really isn�t on the same page as e commerce web hosting I am certainly glad I came across your blog. There are a ton of great view points on this blog. Well I think I can here the kids screaming in the background. I put you in my internet favorites and I will certainly come back and visit. If you want to take a peek at my site you can find me here at http://www.massinternetservices.com. I update my site very frequently. Again, great job blogging and I will be back again soon!

Foulla said...

hi ibahrine,
voisi un article sur ton post.http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/globalvoices/2006/01/18/fatwas-and-tragediesin-the-moroccan-blogs/

Robbie said...

Hello! I have seen your blog. Congrats! I think I write to you some words because in my opinion: your blog is nice and interesting :) Also I have one blog from the radar detector. If you have pleasure, please look at my blog

Robbie said...

Hello! I have seen your blog. Congrats! I think I write to you some words because in my opinion: your blog is nice and interesting :) Also I have one blog from the radar detector. If you have pleasure, please look at my blog

Anonymous said...

[b]its here [/b]

[url=http://phentermine.myeasyseek.info]phentermine search[/url]
[url=http://phentermine.viagram.info]phentermine[/url]
[url=http://tramadol.themysearch.info]tramadol[/url]
[url=http://cialis.ringtoners.info]cialis[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://phentermine.networkfindwork.info]Phentermine[/url]
[url=http://phentermine.worksearchuk.info]Phentermine search[/url]
[url=http://ringtone.worksearchsolutions.info]Ringtone search[/url]
[url=http://tramadol.eworksearch.info]Tramadol[/url]
[url=http://phentermine.uniqringtone.info]Phentermine[/url]
[url=http://cialis.goodtone.info]cialis[/url]

Anonymous said...

Learn how to install your Webserver Software & How to install PHP, MYSQL,PERL,PHPMYADMIN + MORE 100% FREE

YOU'LL DISCOVER...

How to host unlimited websites & domains for free.
How to install Webserver Software on your PC easily.
How to install PHP , MYSQL , PHPMYADMIN, PERL & ZEND... on your PC
Replicator site + MYSERVER Tutorials software to earn lots of money paid instantly to your PAYPAL account + how to promote it to millions 100% FREE.
And Much More...

Go here now : http://lnk.in/4cur

http://lnk.in/4cur

http://lnk.in/4cur

Thank you and hurry.

Anonymous said...

[b] Relax and enjoy [/b]

[url=http://casino.myeasyseek.info]Casino[/url]
[url=http://viagra.themysearch.info]viagra[/url]
[url=http://myownlook.info]tramadol[/url]
[url=http://cialis.workfinda.info]cialis[/url]

THE BEST SIDES said...

Very interesting site :) You can find more information at :
budget car rental cala mandia
lanzarote car rental
luxury car rental uk
pisa car rental
brazil car rental
hertz car rental europe
compare car rental rates
car rental coupon code
rental car sales
Hope it will always be alive! THE END :)

THE BEST SIDES said...

Very interesting site :) You can find more information at :
budget car rental cala mandia
lanzarote car rental
luxury car rental uk
pisa car rental
brazil car rental
hertz car rental europe
compare car rental rates
car rental coupon code
rental car sales
Hope it will always be alive! THE END :)

My Google Profile